If you are a SecondPage member, please click here to login. If you are not a member, check into it now.
2010-05-14
Most links on this page generate a single, additional browser window that you will want to leave active...
Sponsored Links

Editorial: Driving down the costs - Part 1
 
... One of the common questions we get from those outside of the "chip head" side of the industry is, "Why don't they just make the LEDs (and/or solar cells) cheaper? It can't be rocket science." Well, actually, part of it is, or nearly so, and others parts are driven...
Read the editorial...
(if it resists... go here)

Find out how to get
LIGHTimes SecondPage access

Features:

For the latest news dedicated to LEDs in general lighting, tune to Solid State Lighting Design. Applications updates, the latest luminaires and wins, subsystems and componentry in support of lighting in and around the built environment, it's all there!


The 2010-2011 Summit Series is ready to succeed... are you?

After the successful 2008 launch and 2009/2010 expansion of Solid State Lighting Design's SSL Summit in New Jersey, the feedback remains consistent: Just what we needed, do it again soon. The Summit brings together lighting decision makers with industry thought leaders, pioneers, and innovators from the across the solid state lighting eco-system. Read the 2009 conference report...

Following our changes in 2009, 2010-2011 will continue to be all about quality, quality, quality. Showcase participants and sponsors are vetted to separate the wheat from the chaff (have your IES LM-79 test reports ready!). The 2010-2011 Summit includes NY/NJ in September and LA/Long Beach next January. Look into the series information at www.SSLsummit.com for the details. Sponsorships are available for the full series.


Judge Rules on Motions in Rothschild Vrs. Cree Patent Lawsuit; Lawsuit to Go to Jury
LIGHTimes News Staff

May 14, 2010...Gertrude Neumark Rothschild previously filed a patent lawsuit against Cree Inc. in the United States District court in District D of Massachusetts. Rothschild alleged that Cree violated its '618 Patent and '499 Patent. The '618 Patent is entitled "Process for Doping Crystals of Wide Band Gap Semiconductors". The '499 Patent is entitled "Wide Band Gap Semiconductors Having Low Bipolar Resistivity and Method of Formation".

Cree has been one of the only major LED product companies that has not settled with Rothschild about these fundamental LED patents. Cree filed a motion to dismiss for lack of standing based on the argument that Rothschild conceived of the invention while employed at Philips Lumileds Lighting Company L.L.C., making Philips the rightful owner of the patent. In a motion to dismiss, the court may look outside the pleadings to determine if jurisdictional facts exist.

Philips however previously settled with Rothschild. Under the terms of the settlement Philips agreed to abandoned and relinquished any claim to right, title, interest in or ownership of the [patents-in-suit]." For this reason Cree's motion to dismiss was denied. Cree's motion for summary judgement of patent invalidity was also denied. Rothschild made several motions for partial summary judgement about various assertions and claims of the patents. All of these were denied. William G. Young, the district judge in the case in Massachusetts ordered the case to go before a jury.

In 20 of the 21 processes discussed in Cree's motion for summary judgement the Judge ruled that the GaN layer was epitaxially grown and therefore not a substrate. The key issue in the case may come down to whether the AlGaN layer falls within the definition of substrate. If the AlGaN Layer is ruled to be a substrate then Cree would likely be found to infringe Rothschild's patent. If not, there Cree would not be found to infringe Rothchild's patent. There is no word yet on when the jury trial will commence.

Cree Increases Maximum Drive Current for XLamp MX-6 Lighting-Class PLCC LED to 1A
LIGHTimes News Staff

May 13, 2010...Cree has raised the maximum forward drive current for its XLamp MX-6 LEDs to 1 amp. Obviously, a result, the LEDs are drastically brighter, 160 percent brighter, according to Cree. At 1 A of current, XLamp MX-6 LEDs provide up to 300 lumens in cool white (6500 K) and 245 lumens in warm white (3000 K). "By qualifying our XLamp MX-6 LEDs at higher drive currents we are giving customers additional design flexibility," said Paul Thieken, Cree director of marketing, LED Components. Such increases in drive current usually require a trade-off of increased brightness for decreased efficacy and/or lifetime. There has been no word yet from the company on the specifics of the trade-off.

Cree also announced the relaunching of the Raye fixture, which is now based on Cree MX-6 LEDs. "The MX-6 LED has dramatically reduced the power consumption for this cove and wall slot fixture, giving us superior luminaire efficacy. Raye is now a great retrofit option for existing fluorescent cove lighting applications because it delivers the same luminous intensity at 25 percent less power," commented Ann Reo, founder and general manager of IO Lighting which makes the Raye fixture.


Lighting decision makers deserve quality answers, not hype...
  Lighting decision makers for 200 million+ square feet of commercial property will be represented at the SSL industry's quality-focused "insiders meet", September 14-15 in New York City...

They are looking for the keys to quality in LED lighting, and you can not afford to miss it. Just one look at the special guests and NY Summit agenda, and you will know why you need to be there in September!

Building on the continuing success of this first-of-its-kind event, the 2010/2011 Summit series will again deliver the highest quality agenda and attendees in an unsurpassed networking environment. We have expanded the Summit to "take it to the facilities decision makers" in NY, and quality oriented suppliers need to be seen.
See what you need to be part of at www.SSLsummit.com

NNCrystal US Corporation Agrees to Supply Quantum Dot Materials for Acuity Brands Lighting
LIGHTimes News Staff

May 13, 2010...NNCrystal US Corporation of Fayetteville, Arkansas, a maker of colloidal nanocrystal (quantum dot) materials that act as a light coverter, (Ref: Coverage) will soon be supplying them to Acuity Brands Lighting, Inc. for Acuity's LED lighting products. The companies announced Tuesday that they have signed a supply agreement.

"We are excited to secure Acuity Brands Lighting as an early customer of our Qshift technologies in their products. Their focus on delivering highly energy-efficient and innovative lighting solutions serves as key validation of our technology and its game-changing ability," said Dr. Suresh Sunderrajan, President of NNCrystal US Corporation.

Ghirardelli Square Sign Lighting Upgraded with CAO Group’s Dynasty S14 LED Lamps
LIGHTimes News Staff

May 11, 2010...The Ghirardelli Square sign at 900 North Point St. in San Francisco got a lighting upgrade with Dynasty S14 LED lamps from The CAO Group of Salt Lake City, Utah. The 46 year old Ghirardelli sign, which sits 100 feet in the air, features over 1,300 Dynasty S14 lamps. Another 900 Dynasty S14 lamps were installed throughout the Ghirardelli Square property, significantly reducing the energy, and maintenance costs.

The Dynasty S14 LED lamps reportedly only consuming 1.7 watts of electricity per lamp compared to 10-15 watt incandescent lamps used to light the sign previously... LIGHTimes SecondPage members login for more. Guests can view membership details.

Interested in general lighting, architectural applications or LED luminaire product news?

While you're in exactly the right place for the broader LED industry applications and supply chain news, general lighting products and applications have moved over Solid State Lighting Design. See what you've been missing today at www.SolidStateLightingDesign.com.

Wavien, Inc. Licensed Premien Recycling LED Technology to TaYih Industrial Co., Ltd. for Flashlights
LIGHTimes News Staff

May 11, 2010...Wavien of Valencia, California USA and TaYih Industrial Company of Taiwan report that Ta Yih Industrial has licensed Wavien's Premien LED Recycling technology for use in ultra-narrow beam, high-output tactical LED flashlights. Wavien contends that its new design produces over 80% increase in output intensity compared to standard technology.

Wavien' claims that its Premien Recycling Collar is a very low-cost component that captures the wasted light in conventional LED lighting designs, recycles the light, and directs it back into the output beam. LIGHTimes SecondPage members login for more. Guests can view membership details.

PowerSecure's EfficientLights Business Introduces New LED Lighting for Retailers' Walk-in Freezer/Coolers and Open Refrigerated Shelves

May 11, 2010...Power Secure International Inc., of Wake Forest, North Carolina USA announced that its EfficientLights business has introduced a new LED light for walk-in freezer coolers and a new LED light for open refrigerated shelves. The company says that the two new LED lighting products improve the energy efficiency and quality of light in grocery, drug, and convenience stores. The company notes that the lights complement its successful flagship EfficientLights product for refrigerated case doors. The customers of EfficientLights flagship product urged the company to bring the new lights to market. The company boasts that the new lights were designed, tested, and perfected in real world settings, including operating grocery stores of major chains who have installed the Company's flagship EfficientLights product.

Bryan Beatenbough, President of EfficientLights, said, "We are very excited to bring these new products to market. We have been blessed to have a wonderfully successful EfficientLights refrigerated case door product that is improving energy efficiency and lighting in stores across the country, and we can now bring retailers these benefits to additional areas of their stores. Similar to the process we used to develop our flagship product, we designed our new lights in partnership with our customers -- to make sure our light addresses their real-world needs. The release of these new lights to the marketplace represents another major milestone in our plan to bring retailers a full suite of LED lighting for their stores."

Samsung Group to Invest $20.6 Billion Including $7.5 Billion for LED Technology Applications
LIGHTimes News Staff

May 11, 2010...Samsung Group of Seoul Korea says it plans to invest 23.3 trillion won ($20.6 billion) in technologies including solar cells, rechargeable cells for hybrid electric vehicles, LED technologies, biopharmaceuticals and medical devices, a press release stated. Samsung Group's largest individual investment planned is 8.6 trillion won ($7.5 billion) in LED technology applications such as backlit TVs and displays, lighting and car electronics, the release said.

Executives of the Samsung Group's companies announced the plan at a meeting Monday. Samsung indicated that the money would go towards: LED technologies, solar cells, rechargeable cells for hybrid electric vehicles, biopharmaceuticals, and medical devices.Samsung Group expects the expansion to create about 45,000 new jobs and result in an additional 50 trillion won ($44 billion) in annual revenue for affiliate companies through 2020.

"When other global companies hesitate, we must move ahead decisively to take this opportunity, and this will also benefit the country's economy," Lee told Monday's meeting, according to the statement. "Striving to resolve unemployment, we should hire young and highly skilled employees also."

Our news features are reported by the LIGHTimes staff writers.
For submissions or content suggestions, you can contact us using
editor -at - sslighting.net
For more information and to reserve promotion space contact
Info8 -at - sslighting.net
or call +1 (512) 257-9888

Sponsored Links
          
 
Looking for news on LEDs in general lighting?
Solid State Lighting Design is the place to be! If your interest is the higher level view of LED lighting in and around the built environment, SSL Design brings you the latest on applications, luminaires/fixtures, light-engines and their components.
Check it out today...
If you aren't a SecondPage Member yet, you need to find out what you're missing. $99/year includes other key benefits, including a savings of at least $100 off industry events or services
Read more about it...

Commentary & Perspective...

Driving down the costs - Part 1
Tom Griffiths - Publisher

April 29, 2010...One of the common questions we get from those outside of the "chip head" side of the industry is, "Why don't they just make the LEDs (and/or solar cells) cheaper? It can't be rocket science." Well, actually, part of it is, or nearly so, and others parts are driven by the economics including "economies of scale" that everyone is always so knowledgeable about. Make no mistake, we'll get there, but it is a process of innovation that will follow an evolutionary path, helped along with some occasional breakthroughs. In the first of this two-part commentary, we'll cover what's happening to move those costs down at the bottom and in some detail at the top of the chain, with Part 2 aimed at the middle and fleshing out that view from the top a bit more.

Materials and reactors... It all starts, not surprisingly, at the bottom. For those coming from a higher level of the food chain, the simplest analogy the industry offers is that making semiconductors is like making a pizza. You have a crust, called a substrate, that everything is layered on. Then comes the sauce, which is a blend of just the right main ingredients, and little added "spices" that make it unique to the particulars of the kind of pizza you're making. That sauce is the "epitaxial layers" or simply "epi". In this case, you cook it while you add the secret ingredients that make up the sauce, and what you get at the end is an "epi-wafer". Some of the ingredients manufacturers blend include gallium, indium and arsenic (called "source metals"), along with other ingredients, which are basically vaporized and then showered very precisely over the sapphire or silicon-carbide substrate in big things called epitaxial reactors. The most common of the volume production techniques is to use MOCVD, or metal oxide chemical vapor deposition. Taken one word at a time, the name is actually pretty sensible.

Those machines are not cheap, running probably $1.5M to $2M+ each, nor are they simple. They use a lot of electricity and take a fair amount of time to get the layers just right. The rocket science in the machine itself is how to get exactly the right amount of everything even blended, across the whole substrate, on multiple substrates at a time, to tolerances in the range of hundredths of a millimeter. The objective is uniform coverage that minimizes the "defects" which may be holes, or cracks, or shortage or overages of elements in the material that's supposed to be there. How well you do at this step will set the stage for the overall yield, or "percentage of good devices" you get from a wafer. More is better, since you go to all the trouble, time and expense of getting the materials on there, you want every square millimeter to be useful. The reactors take time to do their job, take time to finish one run and set up for the next, and also need maintenance (as you can imagine, flowing a bunch of hot metals at high pressure take their toll on the equipment). There is also a need to purge out anything that's not part of the formula for any particular run, so changing from one color LED, or efficiency level of a solar cell, to another, takes time to clean the previous formula's leftovers out.

Improvements are happening, and while incremental, they are noticeable. A few years back, at one of our Blue conferences in Taiwan, currently the larger of the "Big 2" when it comes to our world of non-silicon epi-reactors, Aixtron, was sharing the migration path to larger wafer sizes. In the simplest context, edges are useless for putting devices on, and the larger the wafer, the lower the ratio of "useless" edge to "useful" interior. A move from 2-inch to 4-inch, and then 4- to 6-inch wafers can provide a substantial increase in the yield per square millimeter from each run if (big if) you can maintain the uniformity. Veeco has made a big push recently to clearly communicate its intention to drive the fabrication costs, from the substrate through a device ready to packaged, down by a factor of 4 by 2015. According to Jim Jenson, Veeco's VP of Marketing for their MOCVD business, these reactors, and their accessories, currently make up about 50% of the capital expense of an LED fab. Their model K465i, introduced in January, has brought in a new approach to the deposition nozzle (technically, their "uniform flow flange") that has enabled a whole bunch of things to get better all at once. Jensen claims that their customers have seen yield improvements from what has traditionally been in the mid-70% range to something more in the 90's with this update. That represents just a yield-based cost reduction of 20-25%. Yield improvements ripple through the whole LED manufacturing process, as a higher percentage of good devices means that for the same amount of work at each step (such as fabrication of the chips and testing), more LEDs get produced. Changes to the line have also shortened the time it takes to get a new reactor up to speed, with recent results being customers having being able to take delivery of one of the reactors, and fully qualify their process on it in just 2.5 months.

LEDs, the other rocket science... It wasn't that long ago that packaged "lighting quality" LEDs were running at $10 for 100 lumens, or 10-cents per lumen (remember, blue and white weren't commercially available until around 2002/2003). Announcements in the last few months have shown us 2-cents per lumen (Cree), then 1.5-cents (Bridgelux), and most recently less than 1-cent for warm white (Intematix, part of today's news). It's assured that Philips, Osram, Nichia and others out there aren't standing pat at 10-cents per, they just didn't happen to specifically promote the price in the their announcements. That's a factor of 10 decrease in something like 5 years. We'll discuss what's driving that in the next installment of this commentary.

Supporting components... Suffice it to say in Part I here that there's room for improvement in both drivers (which feed and control the LEDs) and power supplies (which feed the drivers). The capable and reliable ones aren't cheap, especially when it comes to the power supplies.

Integrated lamps and luminaires... When do we get a $5 LED lightbulb? Maybe never, but not because it can't be done, but rather because it won't make sense to. At some point, a product becomes "cheap enough" that mass market adoption proceeds simply because it is a better solution than what existed before. One of my continuing favorite examples to evaluate some of what is happening, and what we think will happen in this industry, is the progression of the PC market. Introduced in the early 1980's, they started out as $2000 tools, and $1000 toys. You had to really need one for business at $2000, and most mid-sized or larger companies were doing just fine on the "cost per terminal" with their existing minicomputers. Small businesses had nothing in the way of a computer, and couldn't afford the $50,000 to $100,000 or more for their few employees who would benefit. $2000 for the PC, plus another few thousand for what was likely custom software, was way better than paying an extra accountant $30K a year (back then) to do the math on paper. As the business-level machines came closer to $1000, the 20-50 seat installations began to make sense as well, and massive adoption proceeded. Later, $500 PCs put them in most of our homes, but did you notice, they didn't keep heading on down to $300, or less (other than rare deals, so super-strippers)? The distribution channel (retailers) couldn't make the money they needed at that kind of price, and having PCs in every consumer electronics store drove far more sales than a lower price (by mail order) every would. They hit the value point at $500 and have stayed there, with features and capabilities being added, rather than prices proceeding lower.

We can expect to see much the same approach in LEDs, and interestingly, there's a bit of a challenge picking what that number might be. We'll explore some of what is driving that for replacement lamps ("bulbs") and luminaires in the next installment. (Continue to Part 2)...

If you have questions about the solid state lighting and compound semiconductor industries or have
news or views to share, we want to hear from you! Feel free to contact us anytime.

The main office line is +1 (512) 257-9888

 

Current & Recent Company
News Releases


Current SecondPage members may access extended content by logging in here
or Sign up for a LIGHTimes SecondPage membership now


Copyright 2001-2008 by CompoundSemi Online Inc.
Some content under license from Veriphos Communications LLC


All site format, content and technology copyright 2001-2007 by CompoundSemi Online, Inc.
Reproduction, in whole or part, by other than authorized clients, is prohibited. Commercial search engines are authorized for all site links. Links for any other commercial purpose are limited to the home and events pages unless you are a client of Solid State Lighting Net or CompoundSemi Online, Inc.
Static links to news articles, suitable for search engines and newsfeeds (attribution required
for use in news feeds), can be found at http://www.solidstatelighting.net/lightimes/searcharchive/.